Café Lumière
Monday, March 20th, 2006
My friend Jesse works at the Asian American Film Festival every year,
and this year is no exception. He was kind enough to get me in to see
Café Lumière
at the Castro on Sunday night.
This was the new(ish) Hou Hsiao-hsien movie. Shot in Tokyo,
it explicitly establishes itself in the opening credits as being an
homage to Ozu Yasujiro. Critics have jumped on the bandwagon,
calling this film a Tokyo Story for the 21st century.
I take issue with this comparison.
Granted, the camerawork, composition, and
pacing are all pretty Ozu. And a number of establishing shots and at least one
scene were direct copies from Ozu’s work. But the narration completely lacks
Ozu’s detachment and insight, and that’s really the key piece of the
puzzle (at least for me, opinions may vary).
Ozu famously gave his characters time and space to breathe so that the audience could
examine their relationships in great detail. By contrast, Hsiao-hsien gives them breathing
room so that we can watch them mope. He is unable to examine their relationships in any meaningful way. Certainly not in an Ozu-esque way. Relationships here are just a backdrop for introspection-as-spectacle.
If this truly is the movie Ozu would have made had he lived long enough,
then it’s probably a good thing he didn’t.

It did have a lot of neat shots of trains and train stations in Tokyo, though.


send me an email
subscribe via RSS